Consciousness: How Our Brains Turn Matter Into Meaning

1. What is Consciousness?

• Aristotle believed that consciousness exists as a continuum of different types of souls:
  • Plants have a vegetative or nutritive soul, which controls their growth, nutrition and reproduction.
  • Animals have, in addition, a sensitive soul, which allows them to perceive things and move about, and they also have fears and desires.
  • Humans have, in addition, a rational soul that allows them to reason and reflect.
• Locke and Hume came up with a properly materialist view of consciousness, but their explanations did not explain how each individual mind feels like a unified, individual phenomenon, rather than just a mass of unconnected experiences (binding problem)
• Chalmers sees the hard problem of consciousness as explaining this subjective sense we have as individuals of being us, with all that implies in terms of our specific responses to, say, a sunset or a work of art, the particular way we felt when we first fell in love or any personal experience, in purely material terms.

2. Tools and Symbols

• Parrington argues that human self-conscious awareness arose as a consequence of two other unique human attributes - our capacity for language and our ability to continually transform the world around us by designing and using tools.
• Engels, in 1876, proposed that humans first began to diverge significantly from other primates when our ancestors started walking on two legs. This freed the hands for using and designing tools in a systematic way to transform the world around them. Importantly, such design and subsequent use of different types of tools was carried out with other proto-humans in a socially cooperative manner. Because of the need to communicate with their neighbors about how to carry out such innovative actions, our ancestors also began to develop the first forms of language. Subsequently the development of both systematic tool design and use, and language, led to a dramatic growth and restructuring of the brain.
• Practically all of our interactions with the world are through tools that we have created.
• Human language, is an interconnected system of abstract symbols, linked together by grammar in such a way that it can convey complex meaning. It is for this reason that only human beings are able to use language to convey complex ideas like past, present, and future, individual versus society, location in space, and even more abstract concepts.
• We can see tool use and language as activities that do not just guide our interactions with the external world, but also act as "mental tools" that have transformed the brain in the process.
• Vygotsky argued that egocentric speech - children's tendency to talk to themselves as they play - is the first stage in a child starting to organize their actions using words and that while this form of speech seems to disappear, what is actually happening is it becomes internalized as "inner speech", which in adults plays a central role in the organization and development of our thoughts.
• Inner speech differs from outer speech in some important ways. It is likely to be much more rapid, and far more fluid in meaning, than the speech we use in conversation with others. There are also probably different types of inner speech, ranging from that which emerges from our innermost, half-formed thoughts to the type that structures our outer speech when we express ourselves to others.

3. Nerves and Brains

• Neurons contain:
  • A cell body
  • Dendrites - Tendrils that receive incoming signals from other neurons
  • An axon - A long protuberance that conveys signals to the next neuron in the circuit
• When a neuron is stimulated through its dendrites, this triggers an electrical impulse called an "action potential", which races along the axon at speeds that can reach around 200mph in the fastest human neurons. The speed at which impulses can travel along an axon are greatly enhanced by a structure called a "myelin sheath". This is a fatty layer that both protects the axon but also allows the neural signal to jump between gaps in the sheath in a process called "saltatory conduction". At the end of the axon, the electrical impulse is transmitted to a dendrite on the next neuron in the circuit, at a gap between neurons called a "synapse". The action potential does this by stimulating the release of a chemical called a "neurotransmitter" into the synaptic gap. The neurotransmitter diffuses across the gap and, at the other side, it acts like a key in a lock to trigger a cellular response that activates a new action potential in the target neuron.
• The human brain is estimated to contain around 86bn neurons, linked by 100tn connections.
• Neurons make up half the brain. The rest is made up of glial cells including oligodendrocytes, astrocytes, and microglia.

4. Evolving Minds

• Jellyfish are a simple type of large multicellular organism whose nervous system consists of:
  • Sensory neurons - Which pick up signals from the environment.
  • Motor neurons - Which trigger a response in the organism
  • Interneurons - Which coordinate these two activities in the central nervous system (CNS).
• The human brain has three main parts:
  • The forebrain - Includes:
    • The Cerebellum - which has two hemispheres and a highly folded surface cortex
    • The Cortex - Is particularly developed in humans, twice the expected area for a primate of our size
      • Broca's area - For producing words
      • Wernicke's area - For understanding words
      • Sensory and motor maps, with most space taken up by nerves going from and to the lips, tongue and pharynx and to and from the hands and digits.
    • The Limbic System - emotional or lizard brain
      • Thalamus - Central postal-sorting depot channeling information into and out of the cortex
      • Hypothalamus - Underneath the thalamus, regulates thirst, hunger, desire, reproduction, and the body clock
      • Amygdala - Plays a central role in processing emotions, being involved in generating fearful, but also pleasurable sensations
      • Hippocampus - Plays important roles in memory
  • The midbrain - alos involved in processes such as vision, hearing, and movement
  • The hindrain - Includes
    • The Pons, which controls sleep
    • The medulla, which regulates vital functions such as breathing and heart rate
    • The cerebellum (little brain) - With, once again, two hemispheres and a highly folded surface. Involved in regulating and coordinating movement, posture, and balance and also in creativity and imagination.

5. Thought and Reason

• The combination of an almost unlimited vocabulary and an instinct for correct grammar is what provides human beings with the ability to communicate with other humans in a precise fashion and with a creativity that, while often only used in everyday, mundane circumstances, can allow some humans to reach dizzy heights of novel artistic or scientific expression.
• Spoken words, music, visual art, literature and film - all of these symbolic forms might be part of the thought process.
• Because our thoughts are so infused with the conceptual framework that language provides, it is almost impossible for us to imagine how it might feel to not have such a framework. Therefore, as a species, when we distinguish different colors or recognize that something happened in the past, as opposed to something that might happen in the future, or that we are an individual person and therefore distinct from other people, it can be easy to assume that other species have similar feelings.
• Inner speech and other inner symbols act like a transmission belt between thought and outward expression. However, that does not mean that human thought and speech are equivalent, since all our thoughts arise from a biological brain that has much in common with other species' brains.

6. The Sensual World

• All species on Earth, from unicellular bacteria to complex multicellular organisms like ourselves, have evolved ways to detect changes in the environment and respond accordingly, such activity being crucial to their survival. Demonstrating the unity of life on our planet, it is remarkable how similar, at least at the level of molecular biology, mechanisms of sensing the environment are between species. Such unity can be demonstrated by comparing the sense of a bacterium and a human.
• While one part of the visual cortex receives signals relating to an object's shape, another area receives ones about its color and another about whether the object is moving.
• Kittens kept in enclosures painted with only vertical lines never learned to see horizontal ones, for instance, a chair seat, while kittens only exposed to horizontal lines could not make out vertical ones, and would therefore bump into a chair leg.
• Human infants from about 8-10 months of age generally begin to notice the presence of snakes and spiders, avoid heights at the edge of a drop-off and withdraw at a stranger's approach.
• But there seems to be no evidence that human infants' responses to spiders, snakes, drops and strangers are either universal or primarily fearful. Instead, the responses were shown to be highly variable, driven initially primarily by curiosity rather than fear, and were very dependent on the context in which infants encounter such stimuli, for instance, fearful reactions by parents or carers. The extraordinary curiosity that human infants show in their encounters encourages them to explore new things, while maintaining the flexibility to develop a fear if they discover something truly threatening.
• The developing human brain is far more primed to respond to new experiences that the brains of other species, which undoubtedly affects our perception of the world around us.
• Human language provides a means for the expression of abstract concepts such as time and place, self vs other and so on, and through the medium of inner speech this brings abstraction into our inner thoughts. However, such an ability to think in abstract terms also affects the way we perceive the world.
• At the heart of conceptual thinking is the ability to group things hierarchically. In terms of color, this means humans have an overall concept of color, with the individual colors subordinate to this. Similarly, we have an overall concept of shape and subordinate to this are specific shapes, for instance, circles, squares, triangles and so on.
• Language is central to conceptual thinking because it allows us to describe concepts such as colors and shapes, and also to employ even more general terms, such as "characteristics" or "properties".
• Drawing does not require words, although language can accompany it, but it does require an ability to abstract. Such abstraction is shown by the fact that we can recognize a series of crudely drawn lines as a person as equally as we do a finely drawn, or photographic image. This is important in terms of perception because it means we also perceive the world as an abstraction. That such a capacity is a uniquely human ability is shown be the failure of attempts to teach apes representational drawing.

7. Learning and Memory

• In multicellular species with nervous systems, a common theme is that, at the cellular level, learning and memory involves lasting changes in the connections between neurons.
• At the cellular level, memory involves structural changes in the postsynaptic neuron that make it more likely to respond if it is stimulated repeatedly by the same presynaptic neuron. Such changes involve an increase in the number of receptors on the dendrite of the postsynaptic neuron, but also long-lasting changes in the neuronal "cytoskeleton" - a complex, dynamic network of interlinking protein filaments that maintains the cell's shape and regulates the movement of substances within it - and even changes to the genes the neuron expresses, thereby helping reprogram it as par of the learning response. While initially learning was thought to involve only neurons, recent studies have shown the that glial cells play key roles in the alterations in postsynaptic neurons that underpin memory.
• In the early 1950s, Henry Molaison had surgery to remove his hippocampus to help control his epilepsy, and he lost his ability to store short-term memories? Unable to recall daily events or recognize hospital staff taking care of him, and able to converse, but forgetting the content of a conversation only minutes after it had occurred, it was as it he now existed in a perpetual present. Yet he could remember things that had happened to him in his youth, although only generally; thus he was unable to remember details about such events. Intriguingly, he also showed an ability to learn new motor skills. He was able to learn how to play tennis or trace the outline of a five-pointed star in a task where he was only able to see the reflection of the star and his hand holding the pencil in a mirror. Later, he had no recollection of learning these skills, as if only his unconscious mind was remembering them.
• Three main types of memory:
  • Episodic memory - Allows us to record specific events.
  • General memory - Allows us to remember general aspects of our past, such as the school we went to or our parents' occupations.
  • Procedural memory - Allows us to learn new motor skills, like riding a bike or playing piano
• One study suggested that the hippocampus acts as a "convergence zone" that pulls together different bits of information stored in the cortex that relate to different aspects of an event into a coherent whole.
• In another study, one neuron was only activated in a volunteer when they were shown an image of Bill Clinton. In another case, a neuron only became activated in response to an image of Jennifer Aniston. Other neurons responded to images of famous landmarks, like the Eiffel Tower. When shown a picture of Aniston next to the tower, the JA neuron began to respond to pictures of the tower on its own. And a Halle Berry neuron would respon even to the words "Halle Berry", as if it is responding to a concept or abstract entity.
• The hippocampus may somehow act like a kind of memory-laden matrix with all the objects we have remembered in the past mapped onto it via different individual neurons. It can be viewed a a kind of map, at least for spatial memory. It contains "place cells" that help create a memory of the environment so that, put all together they create something like a map

8. Mind Chemistry

• Emotions are as much a part of our consciousness as is our ability to think, conceptualize and rationalize.
• A lack of dopamine in one brain region is thought to be a primary cause of Parkinson's disease, while too much of it is proposed to be responsible for schizophrenia. Depression has long been thought to be due to a deficit in serotonin.
• The amygdala is part of the limbic system with ancient evolutionary origins, and is concerned with fear and anxiety, as well as pleasure.

9. Philosophy of Mind

• -

10. Individual and Society

• Although we believe we think in monologues, inner speech's social structure, and the way our consciousness develops through social interactions as we grow into adults, means that in reality inner speech is a dialogue with different outside voices that have shaped our consciousness in the past.
• Voloshinov proposed that although when we make an utterance, we may think that we are linking the words that come out of our mouths in an original and individual way, actually utterances are heavily dependent on "speech genres". People learn as they go through life that particular circumstances tend to produce specific types of verbal interactions.

11. Information and Meaning

• Because computers only process data in an unconscious fashion, any "information" that is fed into a computer remains meaningless to it, as is the final output that it generates.

12. Chance and Design

• Meaning is somehow created within a brain, since what enters it is raw data, but what emerges is something relevant for the brain's owner. Somehow we need to explain how such a process can occur in the biological brain.
• A particular chemical molecule in food detected by the tongue, or an odorant molecule detected by the nose, will trigger a signaling pathway in sensory neutrons that is highly specific for that molecule. In the same way, the rods and cones of the eye that respond to light of different intensities and wavelengths or the cells of the inner ear that respond to sounds of different amplitudes and frequencies also produce a signaling response that is highly specific to some pattern in the visual or auditory environment.
• In multicellular organisms like ourselves, there has been a dramatic expansion and diversification of signaling pathways since our ancestors evolved from unicellular life. This has allowed such organisms to not only perceive a much greater diversity of chemicals in the environment but also to register changes in their own internal bodily chemicals; adrenaline is one such chemical and another one is oxytocin, the former being central to the response to danger, the latter underlying an emotion such as love.
• While a chance incident may have led to adrenaline-like chemicals first beginning to mediate the response to danger long ago in evolutionary history, it is no accident that chemicals of this type are now associated with attention, alertness and readiness for action, both in the body and the brain, and we can thank natural selection for the initial link and its later evolution.

13. Structure and Function

• Similar parts of the brain are activated when volunteers are asked to remember past events or imagine things that might happen to them in the future. Individuals who have a damaged hippocampus, which is associated with memory, tend also to have issues with imagining the future.
• The hypothalamus regulates body temperature, appetite and thirst, the body clock and sexual desire, and is so important that if it is destroyed, the individual is usually unable to survive.
• Phineas Gage in 1848 suffered damage to the prefrontal cortex and much research suggests that similar victims tend to perform poorly on tasks that require the use of long-term strategies and the inhibition of impulses, and can also have short-term memory problems and blunted emotional responses.

14. Circuits and Waves

• The brain is basically an electrical device.
• Different mental states are associated with different frequencies of brain waves:
  • Alpha waves (9-14Hz) - Relaxed state of mind
  • Beta waves (1-30Hz) - Alert state
  • Gamma waves (31-100Hz) - Problem solving and communication
  • Theta waves (4-8Hz) - Deep relaxation
  • Delta waves (1-3Hz) - Deep, dreamless sleep
• Any particular neuron will have inputs to its dendrites from the axons of many other neurons, with this relationship being a highly dynamic one, with the balance between excitation and inhibition constantly changing. Neurons will typically show regular oscillations in their electrical potential. This is the basis for brain waves and the different frequencies of these waves simply reflect the balance between excitation and inhibition in a particular neuron.
• Earl Miller speaks of "working memory" as the "sketchpad of conscious thought", which has a volitional quality: "It is the main mechanism by which your brain wrests control from the environment and puts it under its own control. Any simple creature can just react the environment. But what higher order animals have evolved is the ability to take control over their own thoughts.
• Given its proposed primary role in executive or controlling aspects of consciousness, the prefrontal cortex should be a key mediator of working memory. However it has to do so by coordinating the behavior of other parts of the brain: memory, definitely, but also visual and other sensory inputs, and also brain regions responsible for motivation.
• Pascal Fries has shown that gamma waves are coordinators of sensory input, beta waves are top-down regulators of such input by higher brain regions, and theta waves seem to play a particular role in shifting attention, the process by which our minds stop focusing on one feature of the world and begin focusing on another feature instead.
• Since neuronal ensembles can be rapidly assembled and disassembled, in the process affecting the balance between different brain regions and bottom-u^vs top-down signals, this could explain how thoughts can rapidly come and go in our consciousness.

15. Free Will and Selfhood

• -

16. Consciousness and the Unconscious

• Control by the brain of our breathing, our heart rate, and a vast range of other bodily functions as well as procedural memory largely involve unconscious actions.
• Inner speech appears to be much more rapid than external speech, maybe ten times as fast. It doesn't require the rate-limiting apparatus of the mouth, tongue, throat, and vocal cords;
  • It seems to be more telegraphic than external speech
  • It seems to be more fragmentary and less fully formed.
• Rather than being a separate entity, we can see the unconscious as more a manifestation of the fact that the inner dialogue in our heads is far from straightforward and instead reflects contradictions that can be difficult to express, never mind resolve, and also things that remain unsaid, even in our innermost thoughts, because of the impact this might have on our sense of right and wrong.
• Voloshinov argued that the unconscious represents the least articulate part of the continuous dialogue taking place in our heads because the themes with which it is concerned are those where the official ideology of society is most at variance with a person's actual experience.
• Gramsci spoke of "contradictory consciousness" to express the idea that people can hold two opposing opinions about a subject.
• Hunter-gatherer society tends to be above all about cooperation, minimizing conflict and ensuring that everyone's role is respected.
• About 12k ya, when the Natufians, a group of hunter-gatherers in an area that is now Lebanon, first made the move from hunting ad gathering to agriculture. This would lead to the rise of the first city states and the birth of a human civilization whose development continues to spread across the world, in ever greater complexity and technological power.
• The first city-states were built on extracting value from the surrounding countryside by taxation and force, amassing increasingly larger tracts of land and possessions by warfare, and from such wars capturing human beings and turning them into slaves, who then carried out the bulk of work in these societies.
• Less than 10k years before Aristotle, humans only existed in hunter-gatherer groups organized along principles of strict equality. But by his time, a class of people had risen to the top of society and had not only developed an ideology that justified to themselves behavior that today we would find both reprehensible and indefensible, but also, at the same time, created a ruling ideology that presumably most people in that society believed.
• Feudal society followed the ancient slave societies. While slavery no longer existed, the subjugation of the peasant by the aristocracy was both justified by the ideology of the time, in which religion had an important role to play, but also enforced by military might.
• In contrast, the revolutions that occurred in the A7th and 18th centuries in the Netherlands, England, the USA and France that first brought the capitalist class to power, were inspired by statements such as "all men are created equal". Yet a glance at the world today reveals striking inequality.

17. Modernity and Its Contradictions

• At the heart of modern society lies a contradiction. On the one hand, the capitalist system that now dominates the world is not just the most dynamic in world history, but in its achievements dwarfs anything realized by past societies. But it also has a tendency to instability, crisis and ultimately, unsustainability.
• Liberal democracies are not the majority state of affairs (maybe 70% of people live in some form of dictatorship) but even in such democracies there are growing levels of inequality.
• Adam Smith:
  • Under capitalism, anything can become a commodity if someone is willing to buy it.
  • This is a system of opposition between the producer seeking to maximize profits and the consumer wanting to pay the lowest price possible.
  • Production can become more efficient by dividing up complex processes requiring multiple skills for a single individual to perform, into separate operations, each requiring must less skill.
• Marx: "The worker feels himself only when he is not working, when he is working, he does not feel himself."
• To survive and reproduce, our brains have evolved to work in tow often opposing directions:
  • One is a tendency to keep doing the same things that have kept a species alive and reproductive across many generations. This is rooted in the more primeval parts of the brain, and may explain why it can take a considerable change to make someone consider changing the status quo.
  • The other is the ability to respond rapidly to any threat to that status quo.
    • The amygdala, a primary mediator of emotional responses is one of the main ways that our brains respond to potentially threatening situations, including through unconscious fears of people of difference.

18. Sanity and Madness

• Schizophrenia may be associated with:
  • 108 different genomic regions.
  • An inappropriate immune response involving a surge in the number and activity of glial cells in the brain
  • Inflammation in the brain
  • Laing: major problems of communication within the schizophrenic's family
  • Sexual, physical and emotional abuse and other childhood experiences
• While schizophrenics retain an ability to communicate with the same words as an unaffected person in terms of the objects they refer to, their words will exist in totally different systems of meaning.
• Normally, voluntary forms of attention emerge as "people who surround the child begin to use various stimuli and means to direct the child's attention and subordinate it to their control." However, in a family situation in which normal communication has broken down, Rund believes that the child has "no opportunity to establish a firm way of focusing attention on the relevant stimuli in a given situation, because it will never know which are the relevant stimuli. Instead, the attentional styles that are internalized will be characterized by a steady wandering from one stimulus to another, in a search for the most relevant one."
• Depression may be associated with inflammation, which sparks feelings of hopelessness, unhappiness and fatigue.
• For some schizophrenics, a breakdown of conscious awareness may express itself through an inability to recognize that voices that make up the inner speech within our heads are merely expressions of our individuality and not another person somehow existing inside our heads.
• Depression does not seem to be associated with the breakdown of conscious awareness found with severe schizophrenics.

19. How Ideas Change

• Egypt 1155 BC - First recorded example of strike action.
• Voloshinov's view of human consciousness as a boundary phenomenon, with origins in social discourse but situated in the individual mind, and also being a kind of dialogue: "Meaning does not reside in the word or the soul of the speaker or the soul of the listener. Meaning is the effect of interaction between speaker and listener produced via the material of a particular sound complex. It is like an electric spark... Only the current of verbal intercourse endows a word with the light of meaning.
• Mass movements force individuals into unfamiliar situations and led to new types of cosial interactions with other people in which language plays a key role. This restructuring of neural impulses in the prefrontal cortex could then start to challenge the type of "unconscious biases" that are rooted in the amygdala.
• While the ventromedial prefrontal cortex is involved in guiding our future actions based on things that have happened to us in the past, in contrast, the dorsomedial part of this brain region allows us to adjust our behavior to a rapidly changing situation.

20. Future of Mind

• Investigating how language affects the coordinating role of different brain waves associated with various aspects of human consciousness is likely to be a fertile are for future studies.
• It is possible to access another person's mind, through reading a novel, seeing a work of art, hearing a piece of music or watching a film.